| 
  • If you are citizen of an European Union member nation, you may not use this service unless you are at least 16 years old.

  • You already know Dokkio is an AI-powered assistant to organize & manage your digital files & messages. Very soon, Dokkio will support Outlook as well as One Drive. Check it out today!

View
 

Team 5 Hurricane

Page history last edited by Sharon Dressel 12 years, 5 months ago

 Discussion Home | Volcano | Dust BowlHurricane | Ocean | Final Project

 

Galveston Hurricane of 1900 preliminary discussion below
Click Here for Galveston Hurricane of 1900 ESS Analysis

 

ESSEA Riders Team Discussion: Galveston Hurricane of 1900

 

Working Problem Statement: 

The Galveston Hurricane of 1900 delivered a valuable lesson on the seriousness of hurricane preparedness. Have cities gone far enough to prepare for atmospheric changes that can lead to hurricanes and the resulting impacts to the lithosphere, hydrosphere, and biosphere that hurricanes can cause? In addition, are global climate changes impacting the severity and frequency of hurricanes, and if so, which areas around the world still need improvements in hurricane preparedness?

 

Team Questions & Answers:

  • Are meteorologists better at predicting the path of hurricanes today than they were in the 1900s? There have been considerable advancements made in hurricane preparedness. Specially equipped aircraft can fly into winds to gather crucial data, forecasters have a greater understanding of hurricane behavior, and computer models are much more accurate. All major coastal cities have planned evacuation routes, shelters, and stringent building codes to cope with severe weather. Some of our teammates live/have lived in hurricane prone areas and experience(d) first hand the major changes have occurred in areas of tracking and hurricane preparedness.

  • Are current changes to the global climate producing more frequent and severe hurricanes than Earth experienced in the past? A look at the statistics for the amount of hurricanes that have hit the U.S. since 1851 reveals that most decades are fairly consistent around the average of 17.7/decade. In fact recent decades have actually had lower numbers of hurricanes having made landfall in the U.S. Additionally since 1971, the more severe hurricanes of category 3-5 have been below the average of 6/decade. Weather can be forecasted fairly accurately these days but still is very unpredictable.

2007 

2008 
   
2009  2010 
   

 

  • Did the changes in air pressure in 1900 produce tornadoes and other serious weather events across the plains?
  • How did they rebuild Galveston? Did they raise the sea level of the land? There was a great challenge to rebuild Galveston which included raising the grade for the 500 city blocks from one to ten feet and building a seawall that now spans more than 10 miles of coastline. The seawall is 17 feet tall and provides protection for roughly 1/3 of the island and was key in helping Galveston withstand a Category 3 hurricane in 1915 that had a 16-ft storm surge.
  • How were croplands affected by hurricanes? Obviously current crops are destroyed in the hardest hit areas, but is the valuable topsoil transported from coastal regions inland? Do farmers suffer in some areas when trying tor regrow crops and benefit in others, or does the transported sediment end up where it is not wanted?
  • What has been documented about the effects on the lithosphere, hydrosphere, biosphere, and atmosphere during the 1900 storm? Are my assumptions correct? More research is needed to find out for sure, but quite a lot of documentation has been gathered about the hurricane. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1900_Galveston_hurricane      http://hnn.us/articles/15529.htmlhttp://topics.nytimes.com/topics/reference/timestopics/subjects/h/hurricanes_and_tropical_storms/galveston_hurricane_1900/index.html
  • What changes can we make to improve hurricane preparedness? What can individuals do to prepare? Prior planning is key. Individuals should have a planned evaction route, means to prepare their house, a full tank of gas, hurricane supplies such as food and water, and continually listen for updates from the weather experts. Hurricane Facts and Preparedness
  • Do hurricanes cause a salination problem in croplands and wildlife habitats in coastal regions impacted by seawater flooding? When looking at a recent hurricane, Hurricane Katrina, rice crops dropped by 20 percent due to saltwater intrusion. Soil and waterways were contaminated by saltwater and thus crops could not be planted in normal areas. The only way to prevent this is to increase protection from water such as increased levees.
  • Was poor construction a contributing factor in the high number of fatalities associated with the 1900 Galveston hurricane?
  • Was the population density/concentration different than it is today in the affected area? 
  • How was the devastation and destruction created by the 1900 Galveston hurricane assessed?  By what measure?
  • Was there any possible way to have warned the population and evacuated the people living in the affected area?  Would it have been another Katrina (but in the past)? In 1900 the U.S. Weather Bureau were predicting the path the hurricane would follow and had begun to track it was early as August 30, 8 days before it hit Galveston on September 8, 1900. When the storm had passed Key West on September 6, they were convinced it would continue northeast but they were incorrect as the storm continued west and gained strength in the Gulf of Mexico. It wasn't until September 7 that the local weather office had begun to warn locals by flying the hurricane warning flags. Due to a lack of effective forecasting and communication, the hurricane resulted in comple devestation to the city of Galveston and its residents.
  • Are current evacuation plans effective?
  • Does Galveston use contraflow? The haven't used it yet, but they do plan on using it in the event of a major hurricane threat to the area. http://www.gcoem.org/content/view/16/207/
  • Are people especially those communities that live in areas where hurricanes hit the most aware of the dangers that come along with hurricanes? Over the past several years, U.S. hurricane warning systems (National Weather Service (NWS) have provided adequate time for people on barrier islands and the immediate coastline to move inland when hurricanes threaten. However, due to rapid population growth, it is becoming more difficult to evacuate people from the barrier islands and other coastal areas because roads have not kept pace with the expansion. The problem is further compounded by the fact that 80 to 90 percent of the population now living in hurricane-prone areas have never experienced the core of a "major" hurricane. Many of these people have been through weaker storms. The result is a false impression of a hurricane's damage potential. This often leads to complacency and delayed actions, which could result in the loss of many lives.
  • Do people have plans on what actions to take in case of a hurricane and the hazards that come with them e.g. high winds, tornadoes, storm surge, floods. Some people are prepared and have plans on what actions to take during a hurricane threat, but others especially those new to living in coastal areas aren't aware of the serious dangers of hurricanes.
  • Do the cities along the coast have disaster plans in place (e.g. evacuations routes established, shelters, etc.)? Hurricanes are a natural phenomenon and there is little that humans can do to stop or weaken the hurricanes, but the number of fatalities can definitely can be reduce by proper planning and advance warning. "The National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration's (NOAA's) Tropical Prediction Center and National Weather Service (NWS) field offices team up with other federal, state, and local agencies; rescue and relief organizations; the private sector; and the news media in a huge warning and preparedness effort." http://www.disastercenter.com/guide/hurricane.html 
  • Are there levees in place in the areas where hurricanes tend to make landfall? Levees are built to help contain or control the flow of water to reduce the risk of flooding. The United States has thousands of miles of levee systems in place.
  • Are these levees in good condition, are they maintained on a regular basis? Levees require maintenance on a regular basis so that they don't fail, but they also need to be constructed and designed properly to avoid failure. An example of levee failures are those that occurred during hurricane Katrina. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2005_levee_failures_in_Greater_New_Orleans

 

Hurricanes are part and parcel of life—both past and present—on the Gulf Coast.  Between warm waters, peninsulas and coastlines that jut out into that very temperate Gulf of Mexico (Florida, Louisiana), and marshy barrier islands that are “sitting ducks”, these natural factors offer an invitation to tropical weather systems to both strengthen and strike.  In the case of hurricanes like Katrina, Wilma, and the 1900 Galveston hurricane, what was a “natural” occurrence became quite unnatural, with devastating losses of life and property. 

 

Recommendation:

I do not think there is any way to analyze a specific causation for the 1900 Galveston hurricane, but an analysis of recent hurricanes like Katrina could yield some factors worthy of consideration.

 

One of these possible causes or aggravating factors to think about is the increase in both sea surface temperatures (SST) and the increase in overall global temperature (global warming).  Hurricanes need and feed on warmer temperatures.  There is a belief that increases in surface sea temperatures have led to the increase in hurricane severity and duration (Cohen, 2006).  The increase in sea surface temperatures, some believe, may be attributable to global warming.  And the blame for global warming, some say, lies squarely on the doorstep of the human population and its actions.   

 

While hurricanes like the one that struck Galveston in 1900 cannot be eliminated, the increase in the strength, severity, and duration of hurricanes has led some to believe human actions leading to global warming have caused this uptick. My recommendation is that worldwide governments should institute reforms and control measures that will work to bring down global temperatures that foster the growth and severity of these storms.

 

 

 

Works Cited

Cohen, C. (2006). “Stronger Hurricanes”. Retrieved from http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/earth/stronger-hurricanes.html on September 25, 2011.

Heller, T.(2009).  “Do Hurricanes Affect Global Warming, Which Can Affect Hurricanes?” (blog entry). Retrieved from http://weatherblog.abc13.com/2009/04/do-hurricanes-a.html  on September 25, 2011.

Kieper, M. (2006). “Katrina’s Storm Surge”. Retrieved from http://www.wunderground.com/education/Katrinas_surge_contents.asp on September 25, 2011.

NASA (2003). “How Are Hurricanes Created?”. Retrieved from  http://kids.earth.nasa.gov/archive/hurricane/creation.html  on September 25, 2011

NASA (2004). “NASA Data Shows Hurricans Help Plants Bloom in ‘Ocean Deserts’”. Retrieved from            http://www.nasa.gov/centers/goddard/news/topstory/2004/0602hurricanebloom.html .

NASA (2005). “Arlene to Zeta: 27 Storms of the 2005 Season”. Retrieved from http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0woOxPYJz1U on September 25, 2011.

National Hurricane Center: Hurricane Preparedness. Retrieved from http://www.nhc.noaa.gov/prepare/ on November 3, 2011.

National Hurricane Center: U.S Hurricane Strikes By Decade. Retrieved from http://www.nhc.noaa.gov/pastdec.shtml on November 4, 2011.

NOAA (2007). "The Great Galveston Hurricane of 1900". Retrieved from http://celebrating200years.noaa.gov/magazine/galv_hurricane/welcome.html#intro on November 4, 2011.

Guillot, C. (2006). "Hurricane Katrina's Ecological Legacy: Lost Swamps, Crops, Islands". Retrieved from http://news.nationalgeographic.com/news/2006/08/060823-katrina-ecology.html on November 4, 2011.

NOAA (2011). Storm Surge Overview. http://www.nhc.noaa.gov/surge/#IMPACT

FEMA (2011). Living with Levees – It's a Shared Responsibility. http://www.fema.gov/plan/prevent/fhm/lv_intro.shtm

FEMA (2011). FEMA is Revising its Levee Analysis and Mapping Approach. http://www.fema.gov/plan/prevent/fhm/lv_lamp.shtm

 

 

 

Comments (17)

Jennifer Henson said

at 8:45 pm on Nov 1, 2011

I apologize if you see several comments from me. This makes try number 3 for me to add a comment--not sure what's happening in WikiLand tonight. Thanks, team, for meeting tonight. It was great to hear of your knowledge about hurricanes. I'm also glad to hear that hurricane preparedness has come a long way since 1900 and that this year has been a mild one for hurricanes impacting the U.S. While preparing my ESS analysis, I came up with some questions, which I've shared above. I'd appreciate your insights. I also took a stab at a problem statement. Your edits and improvements are welcomed! Best, Jenji "Forever Landlocked" Henson

Sharon Dressel said

at 11:19 pm on Nov 2, 2011

Dear Jen,

Your comments are always thorough and thought-provoking. Whether we see them once or three times, they are always wonderful!

Sharon Dressel said

at 11:25 pm on Nov 2, 2011

By the way, I, too, am now landlocked and loving it! I grew up in south Louisiana, and hurricane season was something we were very familiar with. If you asked a kid from somewhere else in the country what the dates were for hurricane season, they would probably look back at you with a blank stare! However, a kid growing up where I did in Lafayette, Louisiana, heard about it on a daily basis during the season. We knew when it was coming and when it was supposed to end. Between my hometown in Louisiana and my grandparents and extended family living in Mobile, Alabama (another Gulf Coast locale), hurricanes like Camille, Audrey, Danny, Juan, Andrew, and more are part of my family history and that of my husband who grew up in low-lying Morgan City, Louisiana.

Sharon Dressel said

at 11:31 pm on Nov 2, 2011

Something else that came from watching the nightly weather report during hurricane season...I learned how to do coordinate systems from an early age following the hurricane tracker map that we could pick up at the store or that was printed on the brown paper grocery bags. I knew that if the numbers got close to 90 degrees W and 30 degrees N (includes New Orleans and Lafayette areas), that we were in for a bad time! I learned about the millibars and atmospheric pressure in storms, too...the lower the numbers, the worse the situation!

Ray Slapkunas said

at 8:45 am on Nov 3, 2011

I've spent 5 of past 7 years in Florida, including living in Pensacola when Hurricane Ivan hit. Add that I've been in the Coast Guard for almost 10 years and a first hand responder, you can say I've become quite accustomed to them. Oh and most importantly ,one of my dogs is a Hurricane Ike rescue!

Jennifer Henson said

at 9:38 am on Nov 4, 2011

Thanks for your kind comments, Sharon! I am fascinated to hear that you use hurricane tracker maps to trace the path of a storm. I had no idea that was possible without sophisticated meteorologic equipment! You are a bad-ass! [I hope I can say that online.] Ray, kudos to you for taking in a Hurricane Ike victim. I bet that dog is eternally grateful.

Jennifer Henson said

at 9:40 am on Nov 4, 2011

Sharon, your comments and images are fantastic! You've got me thinking about warming trends in a whole new way! And your ESS puts mine to shame!

Sharon Dressel said

at 7:57 pm on Nov 4, 2011

I can't claim credit for the images, but hopefully my comments are worthy of some admiration!

Sharon Dressel said

at 7:59 pm on Nov 4, 2011

I believe the images are the work of Super Slapkunas, rescuer of dogs and people, and super-tweaker of discussion pages!

Ray Slapkunas said

at 8:28 pm on Nov 4, 2011

Ha! Y'all are the leaders. I just try to keep up!

Previous User said

at 11:07 pm on Nov 4, 2011

Jennifer, I think the problem statement is right on. I don't know as much about hurricanes as you all do, but I've learned a lot just from reading our own team wiki. There hasn't been that many hurricanes in the area where I live, but reading about the Galveston and Katrina hurricanes was a bit scary and very thought provoking. I'm very grateful to be in your team. I've learned tons from you guys.

Jennifer Henson said

at 10:08 am on Nov 5, 2011

Way to go ESSEA Riders. I think our combined set of comments is right on the money. I'll put something together in a doc and send it your way for comment via Email. Wish I could see your air show, Ray. Hope it's easy riding!

Jennifer Henson said

at 10:34 am on Nov 5, 2011

Sharon you've given us a good head start for Cycle B. Thanks for leading the way!

Previous User said

at 10:36 am on Nov 5, 2011

When I first read the Galveston Hurricane of 1900 scenario, I immediately thought how sad it was that so many lives were lost to unpreparedness, but as I keep reading on it, I've come across statements made that the Weather Bureau had a great deal to do with the people not being warned in advance due to the politics of the Weather Bureau at the time. Not certain on how true this could be, but it's pretty scary if it was. http://www.weathernotebook.org/transcripts/2000/03/17.html

Ray Slapkunas said

at 4:31 pm on Nov 5, 2011

Unfortunately despite warning from NOAA and other government agencies, individuals refuse to heed warnings and will not evacuate the area. The disaster of Hurricane Katrina was much worse than it could have been due to the thousands of individuals who refused to leave the area despite a Category 5 storm forecasted to hit a city with an elevation below sea level.

Jennifer Henson said

at 10:57 am on Nov 6, 2011

We had quite a few Katrina evacuees come to Austin. I was working in a soup kitchen at the time and got a number of people from New Orleans come through--many became volunteers. One thing I heard again and again was that there had been so many false alarms over the years that they didn't believe the forecasts. That's a big problem. When warnings come through, people need to know they can trust that warning. These storms are unpredictable, though, so I would image 100% accuracy is difficult to achieve. I wonder what the statistics are on accuracy of hurricanes hitting at predicted strength after evacuation orders have been issued...

Sharon Dressel said

at 4:03 pm on Nov 13, 2011

Kind of like Californians have been waiting for "The Big One", people in New Orleans were thinking "The Big One" would never come. They gambled year after year, and, until 2005, their gambles paid off. Vegas had nothing on the Big Easy when it came to gambling--at least on that count.

You don't have permission to comment on this page.